arloGet the app
2025 · Movie · 1h 47m · R

Caught Stealing

CriticsCritics: 75
AudienceAudience: 7.0

A burned-out former baseball player living in late-1990s New York agrees to care for a neighbor’s cat, only to become entangled in a violent criminal underworld. With dangerous strangers closing in, he must rely on instinct and determination to survive while uncovering what has drawn them to his doorstep.

My take

You’ll likely enjoy this fast, violent, darkly comic crime thriller if you like pulpy New York capers and messy genre fun; Not for you if graphic violence, tonal shifts, or familiar twists wear you down.

Ask me more about it

Where to watch

Cast

Regina KingAustin ButlerZoë KravitzMatt SmithLiev SchreiberVincent D'OnofrioGriffin DunneNikita Kukushkin

Director

Darren Aronofsky

If tonight is a Caught Stealing night…

…these live in the same corner of my head.

Want one picked out for tonight?

Tell me what kind of night it is — I'll do the rest.