arloGet the appMovies like What Lies Beneath
2000 · Movie · PG-13 · your starting pointIf What Lies Beneath is the itch, these scratch it — some louder, some quieter. Free ones first.
Movies like What Lies Beneath, ranked
1. Bone Lake (2024)
The claustrophobic lakeside setting and slow-burn revelation of hidden threats force both couples to question their partners' trustworthiness as reality becomes increasingly distorted.
2. Bodies in the Water (2024)
The same lakeside setting and slow-burn investigation into watery graves creates an atmosphere where psychological unease gives way to concrete horrors lurking beneath the surface.
4. Deep Water (2022)
The claustrophobic dread of a deteriorating marriage masking something sinister unfolds through the same Hitchcockian lens of suspicion, betrayal, and the question of what a spouse is truly capable of.
5. The Secrets She Keeps (2020)
The psychological unraveling of a woman dismissed by those closest to her propels both narratives, as buried secrets and gaslighting within intimate relationships transform domestic spaces into sources of dread.
6. Don't Worry Darling (2022)
The gaslighting husband dismisses his wife's terrifying perceptions while she unravels a sinister conspiracy threatening everything she believed about her marriage and reality.
8. The Night House (2020)
Beth's investigation into her husband's hidden life mirrors the slow-burn dread of uncovering a spouse's deception, with both films using isolated lakeside settings and supernatural ambiguity to blur the line between grief-fueled paranoia and genuine malevolence.
Tell me what kind of night it is — I'll pick the one for you.