Shows like The Pembrokeshire Murders
2021 · Series · TV-14 · your starting pointIf The Pembrokeshire Murders is the itch, these scratch it — some louder, some quieter. Free ones first.
Shows like The Pembrokeshire Murders, ranked

1. Karen Pirie (2022)
Procedural cold case revival with a Scottish detective at the helm, methodically unpacking decades-old evidence while pressure mounts as suspects resurface.

2. Steeltown Murders (2023)
Steeltown Murders uses the same detective-led narrative structure of reopening decades-old Welsh cases by contrasting outdated investigative methods with modern forensic science to finally identify a killer before time runs out.

3. Waking the Dead (2000)
A seasoned detective leads a specialized unit through methodical re-investigations of decades-old cases, applying contemporary forensic science to finally crack crimes that eluded original inquiries.

4. Murdoch Mysteries (2008)
Detective William Murdoch employs the same meticulous forensic ingenuity to unravel decades-old cases, but set against Victorian Toronto's gaslit streets where science battles institutional skepticism at every turn.

5. Cold Case (2003)
Detective John Paul uses methodical re-examination of decades-old evidence and interviews to crack cases that went cold, building the same meticulous investigative momentum as he pursues justice through forensic breakthroughs.

6. The Murders (2019)
Luke Evans' methodical approach to cold case investigation mirrors the procedural rigor of modern forensics solving decades-old crimes through painstaking detail work.

7. Blue Murder (2003)
Luke Evans's methodical detective work and the meticulous reconstruction of decades-old crimes through forensic detail mirror the procedural rigor and character-driven tension that define this Manchester-set investigation of a DCI balancing personal turmoil with solving complex murders.

8. Murder, Mystery and My Family (2018)
Jeremy Dein and Sasha Wass apply the same meticulous legal scrutiny to decades-old cases that the Pembrokeshire team uses to crack cold murders, examining whether justice was truly served.
Tell me what kind of night it is — I'll pick the one for you.