Shows like The Jetty

If you want that blend of claustrophobic small-town dread and a detective psychologically unraveling while excavating buried secrets, you'd probably find similar ground in The Long Call, The Dry, or The Gulf—all three use tight community settings and professional compromises to build pressure, though none quite nail the specific tension between institutional power and consent that The Jetty foregrounds. Devils Lake and Widow's Bay might scratch a different itch if you're after creeping psychological horror wrapped around local corruption, while Beyond Lochness and Bodies in the Water lean harder on water itself as both setting and metaphor for what refuses to surface. The Bay and Cold Case are probable hits if what drew you in was watching a detective's judgment fracture under the weight of proximity to trauma.