arloGet the appShows like The Jetty
2024 · Series · TV-MA · your starting pointIf The Jetty is the itch, these scratch it — some louder, some quieter. Free ones first.
Shows like The Jetty, ranked
1. Devils Lake (2021)
This claustrophobic mystery uses a returning protagonist's haunted history with a small town to unearth dark secrets buried beneath its surface, mirroring the psychological toll of excavating a cold case in an insular community.
2. Bodies in the Water (2024)
The documentary's methodical excavation of submerged crime scenes mirrors the detective's painstaking dissection of buried secrets, with both narratives using water as a literal and psychological barrier between hidden truths and justice.
3. The Bay (2019)
The Bay's exploration of how a detective's emotional entanglement with a missing persons case compromises her judgment mirrors The Jetty's examination of professional boundaries fractured by proximity to trauma and secrets.
4. Caddo Lake (2024)
The isolated wetland setting and methodical unraveling of connected disappearances through overlapping timelines create the same suffocating sense of dread, where digging into the past threatens to destroy the present.
5. Widow's Bay (2026)
This small-town mystery uses creeping dread and buried secrets to expose how institutional power corrupts personal safety, much like The Jetty's examination of consent and authority through its lakeside investigation.
6. Bone Lake (2024)
The claustrophobic power dynamics and moral ambiguity that simmer beneath polite surfaces in small-town settings drive both narratives toward psychological breaking points.
7. Somebody Knows Something (2026)
The methodical unraveling of a decades-old disappearance through painstaking investigation and the revelation of uncomfortable power dynamics within tight-knit communities drives both narratives forward with mounting dread.
Tell me what kind of night it is — I'll pick the one for you.