arloGet the appMovies like Thanksgiving
2023 · Movie · your starting pointIf Thanksgiving is the itch, these scratch it — some louder, some quieter. Free ones first.
Movies like Thanksgiving, ranked
1. The Priest: Thanksgiving Massacre (2025)
This isolated cabin massacre shares Thanksgiving's obsession with how holiday trauma warps a killer's identity, building dread through a community's dark secrets rather than jump scares.
2. Halloween (2018)
Eli Roth's kinetic slasher energy carries over in this Michael Myers origin story that weaponizes a holiday's commercial excess into genuine dread, with a masked killer whose ritualistic brutality stems from a town's collective trauma.
3. Slender Man (2018)
The masked killer methodically stalking a tight-knit Massachusetts community creates the same claustrophobic dread and whodunit structure, with young protagonists racing to identify their hunter before the next body falls.
4. Terror of Hallow's Eve (2017)
The film's masked killer stalking a small town and methodical reveal of a holiday-rooted grudge shares the same slasher mechanics and seasonal revenge framework that drives the narrative tension.
5. Beyond the Mask (2015)
This colonial-era vigilante thriller channels the same slow-burn mystery engine as it builds toward reveals about a masked avenger's true motivations and the trauma driving their violent crusade.
6. Halloween Kills (2021)
This slasher channels the same relentless masked killer stalking a small town while residents band together to stop him, with Blumhouse's signature blend of practical gore and community-under-siege tension.
7. The Group (2021)
A masked avenger punishing a town for collective guilt delivers the same claustrophobic cat-and-mouse tension as this siege thriller, where past sins become the killer's justification.
8. The Terror Of Hallow's Eve (2017)
A masked killer hunting a small town through ritualistic holiday violence—this slasher channels the same slow-burn dread and community-wide paranoia, with each kill tied to the perpetrator's warped obsession with a traumatic event.
Tell me what kind of night it is — I'll pick the one for you.