arloGet the appMovies like Penny Lane Is Dead
2025 · Movie · your starting pointIf Penny Lane Is Dead is the itch, these scratch it — some louder, some quieter. Free ones first.
Movies like Penny Lane Is Dead, ranked
1. I Know What You Did Last Summer (1997)
A prank-gone-wrong setup spirals into survival horror as a tight friend group faces consequences at a coastal setting, mirroring the masked-killer stalking and summer-season dread that defined '90s slasher tension.
2. Summerween (2026)
The isolated setting and fractured group dynamic mirror the beach house siege, while both films weaponize a celebratory atmosphere into escalating dread through dark humor and practical gore.
3. Totally Killer (2023)
The sun-soaked setting and irreverent humor mask genuine dread as a group of young people must outsmart a relentless killer, blending '80s nostalgia with escalating body-count tension.
4. The Contenders (2009)
A beach house gathering spirals into chaos when a single death forces the remaining guests to confront uncomfortable truths, blending dark comedy with the mounting dread of friends trapped together through a long, consequential night.
Tell me what kind of night it is — I'll pick the one for you.