arloGet the appMovies like Heretic
2024 · Movie · R · your starting pointIf Heretic is the itch, these scratch it — some louder, some quieter. Free ones first.
Movies like Heretic, ranked
1. The Taking (2012)
The Taking traps its victims in the same claustrophobic cat-and-mouse dynamic where captors weaponize psychological manipulation before resorting to supernatural threat, forcing prisoners to outwit their captors through sheer will and desperation.
2. Heresy (2024)
A cerebral antagonist weaponizes theological argument to trap his victims in an isolated setting, much like how Heresy's village becomes a pressure cooker where faith itself becomes the most dangerous threat.
3. Is God Is (2026)
The claustrophobic cat-and-mouse dynamic between captive and captor returns here, but with twin sisters locked in a blood-soaked vendetta that tests loyalty and morality just as relentlessly as theological interrogation.
4. The Mission (1986)
Robert Redford and Jeremy Irons confront the cost of idealism when faith meets violence in this methodical thriller about missionaries tested by forces beyond their control.
6. The Devil Lives Here (2015)
A charismatic antagonist traps unsuspecting visitors in an isolated setting where theological terror becomes the weapon in this Argentine ritual-horror film that shares Heretic's obsession with faith as a battleground for psychological manipulation.
7. Leviticus (2026)
The claustrophobic cat-and-mouse dynamic between captor and captive returns here, but this time the threat exploits desire rather than doctrine, trapping two protagonists in a rural setting where escape proves psychologically as challenging as it is physical.
8. Harlow's Haunt (2021)
The cat-and-mouse interrogation between captor and captive that defines Heretic's claustrophobic tension returns here as a vengeful supernatural force systematically isolates and psychologically decimates its prey through calculated, patient stalking.
Tell me what kind of night it is — I'll pick the one for you.