arloGet the appShows like Carnival Row
2019 · Series · TV-MA · your starting pointIf you want Carnival Row's blend of gothic atmosphere, morally compromised investigators, and the slow unraveling of institutional corruption beneath supernatural intrigue, you'd probably connect with Ripper Street or The City and the City—both nail that procedural tension where the investigation itself becomes entangled with the detective's complicity. Bright offers a more direct match if you're after the noir sensibility and systemic prejudice angle with magical creatures, while Grimm might scratch the itch for how a hidden supernatural world operates beneath a city's official surface, though it skews lighter in tone.
Shows like Carnival Row, ranked
1. Grimm (2011)
A homicide detective's investigation spirals into supernatural territory when he uncovers a hidden world operating beneath the city's surface, forcing him to navigate both police procedure and the darker truths his gift reveals.
2. Riley Parra: Better Angels (2018)
The atmospheric, gas-lit detective procedural structure pairs perfectly with Riley Parra's exploration of a morally compromised investigator navigating both supernatural intrigue and institutional corruption.
3. Suspects (2014)
Procedural investigations layered with moral ambiguity—detectives pursuing truth while institutional pressures and personal stakes complicate every lead.
5. Colors of Evil: Black (2026)
The prosecutor's obsessive investigation into ritualistic violence within an insular, superstition-haunted community mirrors the detective's desperate hunt through a city where prejudice and supernatural terror blur the line between victim and perpetrator.
6. Ripper Street (2012)
The atmospheric Victorian crime procedural structure and morally compromised detective protagonist navigating brutal murders amid social upheaval creates the same gritty, paranoid investigation that unfolds across both series.
7. The Murders (2019)
The gothic procedural atmosphere and morally compromised detective at the center of an investigation they're entangled in will resonate with anyone drawn to Carnival Row's blend of noir mystery and dark institutional corruption.
8. Lord of Mysteries (2025)
The Victorian gothic atmosphere and corrupt institutional forces hunting a protagonist caught between supernatural factions create the same moral ambiguity and layered mystery that drives both narratives forward.
Tell me what kind of night it is — I'll pick the one for you.