arloGet the appShows like Beyond Paradise
2023 · Series · TV-PG · your starting pointIf Beyond Paradise is the itch, these scratch it — some louder, some quieter. Free ones first.
Shows like Beyond Paradise, ranked
1. Return to Paradise (2024)
Mackenzie's return to her coastal hometown to rebuild trust while solving murders mirrors Humphrey's struggle to establish authority in a tight-knit community where outsider status complicates every investigation.
2. Almost Paradise (Season 1 & 2) (2020)
A former operative seeks refuge on a tropical island only to find himself drawn into solving local crimes, mirroring the fish-out-of-water detective premise but with higher stakes and more explosive action sequences.
3. Paradise (2025)
The investigation of concealed violence within seemingly idyllic communities and the tension between outward tranquility and underlying criminal intrigue drives both series' narrative engine.
4. Death in Paradise (2011)
The same director crafts both shows around a fish-out-of-water British detective solving murders in unfamiliar terrain, balancing procedural investigation with the clash between policing philosophy and local community dynamics.
5. Almost Paradise (2020)
Walker's forced retirement to a serene tropical setting crumbles just like Humphrey's does when past skills become unavoidable in a crime-ridden community that demands his expertise.
6. Blood Paradise (2019)
Detective work in deceptively charming small towns reveals how isolation breeds darker secrets, whether you're investigating actual crimes or stumbling into them as an outsider.
7. Bergerac (1981)
Humphrey's fish-out-of-water detective work in a deceptively crime-ridden island community mirrors Bergerac's approach to solving cases on Jersey while butting heads with bureaucracy and his own demons.
8. The Paradise Murders (2025)
A detective navigating small-town secrets while uncovering hidden darkness beneath a picturesque surface drives this resort-set mystery where tranquility masks dangerous deception.
Tell me what kind of night it is — I'll pick the one for you.