Movies like

Movies like Beautiful Creatures

2013 · Movie · PG-13 · your starting point

Why these

If Beautiful Creatures is the itch, these scratch it — some louder, some quieter. Free ones first.

Movies like Beautiful Creatures, ranked

1. After (2019)

The supernatural weight pressing on a first love—whether through magical forces or emotional intensity—forces both protagonists to choose between the safe worlds they've known and the transformative pull of a mysterious stranger.

Netflix Fandango at Home Amazon AppleTV Google Play

2. The Mortal Instruments: City of Bones (2013)

Lily's sixteenth-birthday curse mirrors Clary's discovery of her Shadowhunter heritage—both heroines navigate supernatural worlds where their newfound identity forces impossible choices between love and duty.

YouTube Netflix AppleTV Amazon Fandango at Home Google Play

3. Twilight (2008)

Ethan and Bella both discover that their seemingly ordinary towns harbor supernatural secrets, and each falls for a classmate whose dark nature forces them to choose between love and safety during a pivotal moment of magical destiny.

Netflix Fandango at Home Amazon AppleTV Plex

4. The Twilight Saga: Eclipse (2010)

The tension between supernatural factions threatening your protagonist's choice—and their forbidden romance—mirrors the werewolf-versus-vampire conflict that tests Bella's loyalty as graduation looms.

Pluto TV Netflix Prime Video AppleTV Amazon Fandango at Home Google Play Plex

5. Teen Wolf (2011)

Tyler Hoechlin's brooding supernatural romance captures the same slow-burn tension between ordinary teens and their cursed lovers navigating a hidden magical hierarchy that threatens to tear them apart.

Amazon Freevee Prime Video Free Prime Video Netflix fuboTV MGM+ (Via Amazon Prime)Spectrum On Demand Philo MGM Plus Roku Premium Channel MGM+DirecTV On Demand Google Play AppleTV Fandango at Home Amazon

6. Wednesday (2022)

The fatalistic romance between outcasts navigates supernatural destiny and dark family legacy through moody Gothic aesthetics and a protagonist grappling with predetermined darkness on the eve of transformative power.

Netflix

7. Fallen (2016)

The supernatural romance between morally ambiguous love interests unfolds against a gothic backdrop where a girl's hidden nature forces her to choose between two worlds that pull her in opposing directions.

YouTube Tubi TV AppleTV Fandango at Home Amazon Spectrum On Demand

8. Miss Peregrine's Home for Peculiar Children (2016)

Tim Burton's whimsical-yet-gothic visual style frames a supernatural coming-of-age story where a protagonist must navigate a hidden world of peculiar magic and protect those caught between opposing forces.

Disney+Fandango at Home AppleTV Amazon Google Play

Want one picked for tonight?

Tell me what kind of night it is — I'll pick the one for you.

Ask Arlo Get the app